Your healthcare news library

Archive for September 25, 2012

Medical tourism: Asian tigers reign supreme

Unspoiled beaches, dense rain forests, ample wildlife and the tropical climate have made the South East Asian states such as Malaysia and Thailand favourite destinations for tourists from all over the world over the past 20 years.

Finding themselves well positioned to catch the foreign exchange flowing out of the pockets of international travelers, the private sector players in these countries jumped to the fore with hundreds of splendid shopping malls, theme parks and other tourist attractions; all inviting tourists to spend more during their stay.

Over the past two decades, countries such as Malaysia have witnessed rising income levels and the general standard of living of citizens has improved in tandem. Due to the improved purchasing power of the local population, demand for the health and educational sectors has also soared.

Realising the potential benefits of a budding medical industry, the government has actively encouraged private healthcare providers and practitioners alike to set up operations in the country. Now, not only is this sector providing medical services to the local population; it is also eyeing potential clientele abroad.

“Healthcare costs in the West have always been relatively high. But now, as those economies slow down, people are ever more conscious of the affordability of healthcare services as much as they value the quality of these services” explained Sarah Albert from the Island Hospital, Penang in a recent interaction with BR Research.

Singapore has long been a favoured destination for those seeking quality healthcare services at affordable rates. Now its regional peers are also ratcheting up a storm in the sector, developing expertise in myriad medical services.

Malaysia is emerging as a major destination for those seeking knee cap replacement, spinal fusion and other joint-related surgeries and medical procedures.

Meanwhile Thailand is now home to an ever-increasing number of cosmetic surgery and related services providers including liposuction, facelifts and anti-ageing treatments. In India, heart-related ailments are being treated at world-class facilities at rates that are competitive globally. In all these cases, the low cost of quality health care services is a major driving force behind the rising trend of medical tourism to these destinations.

Though only the relatively affluent Pakistanis can afford to travel abroad to receive medical attention for their ailments, the emergence of the Far East as a destination for medical services bodes well for the not-so-wealthy. “Traveling to Malaysia or Thailand is not as expensive as going to Europe or North America and the visa process is also relatively easier. Then the cost of obtaining these services is also much lower in these countries” explained Director of Lahore-based, Waseem Travel and Tours, Malik Muhammad Yaqoob.

Add to this the globally competitive rates and quality of medical services in these countries and it is easy to rationalise the emerging trend of medical tourism there from Pakistan and abroad.

Cost of Medical Procedures
USD   US India Thailand  Singapore Malaysia
Heart Valve Replacement        160,000         9,000         10,000         12,500           9,000
Hip Replacement          43,000         9,000         12,000         12,000         10,000
Hyterectomy          20,000         3,000           4,500           6,000           3,000
Knee Replacement          40,000         8,500         10,000         13,000           8,000
Spinal Fusion          62,000         5,500           7,000           9,000           6,000

Business Recorder

留台聯總:牙醫法案將呈國會‧遺憾台牙醫系不受承認

(雪蘭莪‧八打靈再也23日訊)衛生部將在這次國會提呈“2012年牙醫法案”,以取代1971年牙醫法令,而在提呈正式受承認各國大學牙醫系的名單中,沒有台灣大專的牙醫學系,留台聯總深表遺憾與失望。

該會今日發文告說,台灣大專學術水平至今受到世界大多數國家的肯定,而各擁有牙科學系的7所台灣大學,即台灣大學、陽明大學、國防醫學院、中山醫學大學、高雄醫學大學、中國醫藥大學及台北醫學大學的專業知識與學術水平更是受到高度的認可。

文告說,上述7所台灣大專的牙醫學系畢業生在1971年牙醫法令下,是屬於有條件地受到政府承認。

馬牙醫與人民比例1:7千文告指出,根據世界衛生組織的理想牙醫與人口比例為1對4千人,但根據砂拉越衛生局口腔衛生署理局長謝日書指出,我國牙醫短缺,國內目前只有約4千至5千名牙科醫生,牙醫與人民比例為1對7千人;砂拉越州比率更為1對1萬1千人。

“國內目前擁有12間牙科學院,即使到了2015年,每年也僅栽培850位牙科畢業生。因此,為了彌補我國牙醫短缺問題,鼓勵留台生回國服務更是一個刻不容緩的問題。”

文告說,目前,高教部、大馬學術資格鑑定機構(MQA)、馬來西亞留台校友會聯合總會、駐馬台北經濟文化辦事處及台灣高等教育評鑑中心基金會(HEEACT)的共同努力下,眾所期待的台馬雙邊學歷承認議題,在今年有了重大的突破。

“台灣157所大專校院經評鑑通過後,其學歷均可獲得MQA承認,而且承認時間將追溯至2011年6月20日以後畢業的學生。”

諸多限制如何鼓勵專才回國

文告說,我國政府在積極鼓勵留台生及國外留學生畢業後回國服務,並提供諸多優惠,以期回國貢獻,促進國家發展,倘若在此前提下又諸多限制,又如何能鼓勵優秀人才回國發展?

該會期望馬來西亞牙醫理事會重新評估,將台灣擁有牙醫學系的大專學府,無條件納入符合承認資格的大學名單,以利學子學成歸來服務人民。

牙醫:口腔保健比我國先進20年
“台牙醫系不受承認不公”

據一名不願透露姓名的牙醫向星洲日報指出,“2012年牙醫法案”列出了各國受承認的大學牙醫系,當中包括美國、英國、新加坡、日本、韓國、印度、印尼、埃及和土耳其大學等。

“難道在過去的三四十年,台灣大學牙醫系畢業生在國內的表現無法給予肯定嗎?此舉相較其他各國大學無條件獲得承認,有欠公平及有所偏見。”

他坦言,台灣口腔醫療保健比我國先進20年,衛生部應該把台灣大學的牙醫系列入正式受承認的大學名單。

台畢業生何去何從

他說,若台灣大學牙醫系被列入正式受承認的清單,台灣牙醫系畢業生就可以與本地大學牙醫系畢業生享有同等待遇,即畢業後直接向大馬牙醫理事會注冊,並且在政府醫院服務2至3年後,就可自行開業或在私人界服務。

“在1971年牙醫法令第12條文(3)下,沒工作經驗的留台畢業生需在政府醫院實習2年及通過大馬牙醫理事會資格鑑定考試才可獲得資格注冊;而在12條文(9)下,留台牙醫系畢業生須擁有台灣牙醫執照及2年臨床工作經驗,其資格才獲承認。”

他說,2012年牙醫法案通過後將取代1971年牙醫法令,這項新法令闡明將成立評估委員會,以鑑定沒被列入正式受承認清單的大學牙醫系資格。

“因此,未來台灣牙醫系畢業生該何去何從,未有明確規定,這也是令人擔憂的。”

他認為,政府已經全面承認台灣大學的醫學系,但對台灣牙醫系卻持有不同的標準,此做法無法令人苟同。

他說,國立大學的牙醫學額有限,而家境貧窮又想修讀牙醫系的學生惟有選擇到台灣留學,若台灣牙醫系不受承認,也會導致人才外流。

星洲日報